Mechanisms Matter: Evidence for Behavioural Policy
Knowing that an intervention worked once is not enough; we need to know how it works to predict whether it will work again. These papers argue for mechanistic evidence and confront the challenge of individuating mechanisms: at what level of detail must a mechanism be known to guide the choice and transfer of interventions?
- Marchionni, C. & Till Grüne-Yanoff (2026) Mechanistic evidence and the challenge of mechanism individuation, Philosophy of Science accepted for publication May 5th, 2026.“Find the mechanism!” – easy to say. But at what level of detail does a mechanism actually help policy?
- Paunov, Y., Schwirplies, C., Marchionni, C., & Grüne-Yanoff, Till (2025). Few and far between: a scoping review of the mechanistic evidence in empirical research on household energy-saving interventions. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 12(1), 1138.1,591 studies, hardly any tested mechanisms: energy-saving research knows that interventions work, not why or how.
- Grüne-Yanoff, Till, Marchionni, C., & Nuotio, T. (2024). The relevance of mechanisms and mechanistic knowledge for behavioural interventions: the case of household energy consumption. Economics & Philosophy, 40(3), 606-625.Stop sorting policies by what they look like; sort them by how they work.
- Grüne-Yanoff, Till (2021) Behavioral Public Policy: One Name, Many Types. A Mechanistic Perspective. Routledge Handbook of the Philosophy of Economics, eds. C. Heilmann & J. Reiss, 480-93.“Nudge” is not one thing: behavioural public policies come in many kinds, sorted by how they work.
- Grüne-Yanoff, Till, Caterina Marchionni & Markus Feufel (2018) Toward A Framework For Selecting Behavioural Policies: How To Choose Between Boosts And Nudges. Economics and Philosophy 34(2): 243-266.Nudge or boost? It depends – and this paper tells you on what.
- Grüne-Yanoff, Till (2015) Why Behavioural Policy Needs Mechanistic Evidence. Economics and Philosophy, 32 (3): 463-483.Ehy “Evidence-based” interventions without known mechanisms might not deserve that name.